How long are you willing to wait before you finally meet someone in person you have connected with from an online dating site?Many experienced users of online dating and social networking sites know they can present a variety of "challenges", not the least of which is determining whether someone you have made contact with is real, fake, or trying to scam you. It may be the question I am asked most often when someone is seeking my advice. As of now, and for the foreseeable future, the only sure-fire way to authenticate or verify whether someone is real and sincere is to arrange to meet them in person. Ordinarily, I advise someone to do this as soon as possible. An obvious exception to that is if there is any kind of distance involved between them, then meeting in person would require a bit more planning and perhaps some expense. Even under those circumstances, my advice is still to arrange for a face-to-face meeting as soon as you can. So it came as quite a surprise and even a bit of "shock" when I tuned in to the one of the latest episodes of MTV's "Catfish" and learned a lovely young lady was in a "relationship" with someone she only knew from the Internet (and phone) for over 8 years! You read that correctly, 8 years!
In this episode (Season 2, Ep. 4, originally broadcast on 7/17/2013), we are introduced first to a pretty young lady from Texas named "Lauren", who is 22 years old. She had been maintaining an Internet "relationship" with someone from Maryland named "Derek" for over 8 years. The simple math says that Lauren and Derek had started this relationship when she was merely 14 years old, so you can pretty much toss out the first 5 or 6 years as having any real possibility for them to meet in person. But for the last 2 years or so, Lauren had wanted to "see" Derek and had made suggestions to enable that possibility. When she requested to see Derek by webcam he claimed that he couldn't afford one, along with other "reasons". It was at this point that Lauren contacted the producers of Catfish with her story. When Nev and Max read her email on the show, their reaction to it was pretty much the same as mine (surprise and shock). Part of the email explained that Lauren had even broken off an engagement to someone else because it just didn't "feel right" due to the feelings she had for Derek.
Of course, I began to draw certain conclusions about Lauren such as thinking "her elevator doesn't go all the way to the top floor". But, from the moment she was introduced and began to speak, my opinion changed quite a bit. Lauren appears to be a mature, down-to-earth, personable, and intelligent young woman who is also a wonderful mother to an adorable 4 year-old little boy. When you combine those things with being very attractive, it leads you to believe she is neither desperate nor lonely. When she is on camera, she also has a certain "likeability". I found myself rooting for her story to have a fairy-tale ending, while trying to suspend my disbelief. In other words, I had a hard time getting past the idea a "train-wreck" was imminent. You couldn't help but notice that Nev and Max were feeling the same things I was. With that, they began their background investigation into Derek.
Over the years Lauren had gotten pictures of Derek. Nev and Max used their resources to try and authenticate them, but came up empty. They then took his cell phone number to try and verify his identity with it and this became a "smoking gun" moment. A picture appeared of an older African-American male, with graying hair and beard, from somewhere in Virginia who happens to be married. Nev, Max, and I all experienced the same, sinking feeling at that moment. We all thought this poor girl's dream was about to be shattered and "Derek" was going to be exposed as a complete fraud and for who he really was. When presented with this evidence, Lauren still believed Derek was real. She wanted to meet him once and for all. She was either going to meet the love of her life or bring final closure to this 8 year journey. They contacted Derek to set up a "meet" and the trip to Maryland was arranged.
What follows is something only Hollywoood could dream up. Not only is Derek "real", he seems to be exactly what Lauren had anticipated, expected, and hoped he would be. The only things missing, at the moment they see each other in person for the very first time, are the sounds of harp music and images of rainbows. It was truly a "Kodak moment". Even Nev and Max were stunned to see that Derek was exactly who he said he was (you have to keep in mind that the biggest part of their job is to find the strangest and most bizarre online dating experiences). Derek had no explanation as to why his cell phone seems to be registered to someone else, but said he would look into it and take the steps to correct that.
For someone like me, who has frequently expressed disappointment and frustration with the way the media seems to focus only on the failures and tragedies of online dating, I felt a sense of vindication. I tell every single person that seeks my guidance, opinion, and advice that online dating does indeed work and you can make your dreams come true, with some simple knowledge and a willingness to be patient and persevere. In all honesty, I would never recommend putting your life on hold for 8 years to finally meet someone in person. I seriously doubt if I would even recommend 8 months!
Here is what I do recommend:
1 - Understand exactly what online dating and social networking sites are created to do. They are simply a place for you to find others who are looking for potential matches. They also provide ways for you to express your interest in someone or receive interest from another person.
2 - Keep in mind that online dating sites are simply a place for "introductions". After finding someone that may interest you, the sites' basic communications tools give you a means to contact that person, show your interest, have preliminary conversations, and get acquainted.
3 - If you find yourself becoming more attracted to someone, and you sense the feeling is mutual, make arrangements to meet in person as soon as possible. You seriously want to avoid the feeling you are creating a "relationship" before this happens. The only way to know for certain is to meet face-to-face, spend a little time together, and see what develops from that.
“I look forward to reading and responding to all of your remarks, comments, and questions. I truly enjoy helping people and hope you will share your experiences. Meeting someone new and dating should be an exhilarating, enjoyable, pleasant experience and a lot of fun!"
Christopher T. Smith is an online dating consultant and the author of Let’s Meet Our Match – Your Complete Guide to Success in the World of Internet Dating. His book shares many of the experiences he has had as an actual user of Internet dating sites. His valuable expertise and advice has helped many people overcome the difficulties of online dating to have a more pleasant, happier, and stress-free experience. To learn more about Christopher and the book, you can visit his website: LetsMeetOurMatch.com
When I am asked for advice, guidance, or suggestions in my role as an Internet dating consultant/advisor, one of the first things I like to do is review someone's entire online dating site profile. Besides looking at their selection of pictures and how they have "filled in the blanks" by utilizing the various formatted options, I am most interested in seeing and reading their profile narrative. I never cease to be amazed at how far too frequently I read profiles that are more focused on trying to prevent contact then they are on welcoming it. When I read one like that, it immediately evokes an image of a security gate and I need to have the right code in order for the gate to open. Obviously, this is what someone is attempting to do when they create that type of profile narrative. I completely get the idea of "security" and/or "prevention". I then discuss with this person that writing something along these lines could be preventing more than just UNwanted contacts. Quite often their response is something like, "It doesn't seem to stop me from getting too many unwanted ones anyway". It's at this point I usually like to ask Dr. Phil's favorite question: "So, how's that workin' for you?"
The MTV production of "Catfish" is back for season #2. (For those of you who may not be familiar with this show, it's premise is finding people that are using online dating and/or social networking websites in the pursuit of romance and a long-term relationship. The show "follows" someone as they communicate with a person they believe is sincere, looking for the same thing, have established a "connection", and taking the steps to ultimately meet in person. The ending of each episode follows what happens when the the two people meet face-to-face for the first time and it's revealed the "other" person is a fake, fraud, or some type of impostor.) This show has become very popular as we get to watch someone experience their shock, disappointment, and heartbreak at the moment they realize they have been scammed. It seems we will never get tired of watching train wrecks, someone get a pie in the face, smoke an exploding cigar, or get squirted with water.
One of the largest online dating sites, PlentyofFish.com (aka pof.com), recently sent out an email from the founder of POF, Markus Frind, to all of it's members that stated certain types of contact/communication/behavior is no longer going to be acceptable on their website. Here are the key points of that email:
While searching through one of the online dating websites where I am a member, an ad for a site called 
